Summary
*The minimum order is $25
Your cart is empty
Add a menu item to start your order.
When
Sclafani's New York Bagels & Sandwiches
Bagel Packs - Catering
Lunch Sandwiches - Catering
-
Beverages - Catering
-
Bagel By The Bag
-
- Single Bagel
One fresh, hand-crafted new york-style bagel — kettle-boiled and baked to perfection. Crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside.
$2.99- Half Dozen Bagel
Six kettle-boiled, and oven-baked authentic New York-style bagels. Perfectly chewy with a crisp outer crust, our bagels are crafted fresh daily. Choose your favorite flavors or mix and match to create your perfect assortment.
$12.99- Dozen Bagel
Twelve kettle-boiled, and oven-baked authentic New York-style bagels. Perfectly chewy with a crisp outer crust, our bagels are crafted fresh daily. Choose your favorite flavors or mix and match to create your perfect assortment.
$23.99- Bagel Box
A full dozen of our fresh, hand-rolled new york-style bagels, plus your choice of a cream cheese tub and a butter tub. Perfect for family breakfasts, office meetings, or any time you need to share (or stock up on) the best bagels in town. These bagels come pre-sliced and ready to serve.
$30.99 Bagel With Spread
-
Cream Cheese Sides & Tubs
-
- Original Plain Cream Cheese (Side)
Our classic plain cream cheese — rich, smooth, and the perfect match for any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Sometimes simple really is best.
$2.99- Original Plain Cream Cheese (Tub)
Our classic plain cream cheese — rich, smooth, and the perfect match for any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Sometimes simple really is best.
$5.99- Chive Cream Cheese (Side)
Smooth, creamy, and packed with fresh chives, this savory spread is the perfect complement to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Fresh, flavorful, and a deli classic.
$2.99- Chive Cream Cheese (Tub)
Smooth, creamy, and packed with fresh chives, this savory spread is the perfect complement to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Fresh, flavorful, and a deli classic.
$6.99- Strawberry Cream Cheese (Side)
Luscious, creamy, and bursting with real strawberry flavor. A sweet, fruity spread that brings a little sunshine to every one of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Strawberry Cream Cheese (Tub)
Luscious, creamy, and bursting with real strawberry flavor. A sweet, fruity spread that brings a little sunshine to every one of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$6.99- Garden Veggie Cream Cheese (Side)
Smooth, creamy, and packed with crisp garden vegetables, this savory spread brings a fresh, vibrant flavor to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Garden Veggie Cream Cheese (Tub)
Smooth, creamy, and packed with crisp garden vegetables, this savory spread brings a fresh, vibrant flavor to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$6.99- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese (Side)
Rich, creamy, and blended with sweet honey and crunchy walnuts for the perfect balance of smooth and sweet. A delicious upgrade to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A popular pairing with our favorite Cinnamon Raisen Bagel!
$2.99- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese (Tub)
Rich, creamy, and blended with sweet honey and crunchy walnuts for the perfect balance of smooth and sweet. A delicious upgrade to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A popular pairing with our favorite Cinnamon Raisen Bagel!
$6.99- Cheddar Bacon Jalepeno Cream Cheese (Side)
Creamy, savory, and packed with sharp cheddar, crispy bacon, and a kick of jalapeño. This bold spread brings serious flavor and heat to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Cheddar Bacon Jalepeno Cream Cheese (Tub)
Creamy, savory, and packed with sharp cheddar, crispy bacon, and a kick of jalapeño. This bold spread brings serious flavor and heat to any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$7.00- Butter (Side)
A side of rich, creamy butter to spread on any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Butter (Tub)
A side of rich, creamy butter to spread on any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$4.99- Honey Butter (Side)
Sweet, creamy honey butter that proves Texas Roadhouse isn’t the only place famous for it. Perfect for spreading on any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Honey Butter (Tub)
Sweet, creamy honey butter that proves Texas Roadhouse isn’t the only place famous for it. Perfect for spreading on any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$4.99- Peanut Butter (Side)
Side of peanut butter.
$2.99- Nutella
Side of nutella.
$1.99- Chicken Salad (Side)
Our signature chicken salad — made fresh in-house with tender chicken and just the right touch of seasoning. Perfect on its own, with lettuce and tomato, or paired with any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$2.99- Chicken Salad (Tub)
Our signature chicken salad — made fresh in-house with tender chicken and just the right touch of seasoning. Perfect on its own, with lettuce and tomato, or paired with any of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels.
$6.99- Cinna-Sugar Butter (Side)
Cinna-Sugar Butter
$2.99- Cinna-Sugar Butter (Tub)
Cinna-Sugar Butter
$6.99- Pumpkin Cream Cheese (Side)
Pumpkin cream cheese.
$2.99- Pumpkin Cream Cheese (Tub)
Pumpkin cream cheese.
$6.99- Apple Pie Cream Cheese (Side)
Apple pie cream cheese.
$2.99- Apple Pie Cream Cheese (Tub)
Apple pie cream cheese.
$6.99 Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches
-
- 5th Ave & Broadway (Bacon, Egg & Cheese)
A classic breakfast sandwich: bacon, a fluffy egg, and melted cheese, layered inside your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Hot, hearty, and built to satisfy. Try it with a hashbrown or Salt, Pepper, & Ketchup - the Jimmy!
$9.99- The Stallone (Sausage, Egg & Cheese)
Savory sausage, a fluffy egg, and melted cheese, all stacked inside your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A bold, satisfying breakfast sandwich made to fuel your day.
$9.99- The Yankee Clipper (Steak, Egg & Cheese)
Chopped steak, fluffy scrambled eggs, melted cheese, and sweet caramelized onions, stacked on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Big flavors, serious comfort.
$11.99- The Bayonne (Pork Roll/Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese)
Classic pork roll, fluffy egg, and melted cheese, served on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A true East Coast favorite, hearty and packed with flavor.
$9.99- The Grand Central (Fried Chicken, Egg, Cheese & Honey)
Crispy fried chicken, drizzled with hot honey, topped with a fluffy egg and melted cheese, all layered on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Sweet, spicy, and seriously satisfying.
$11.99- The Sinatra (Egg & Cheese)
A timeless classic: fluffy egg and melted cheese, served on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Simple, smooth, and always a hit.
$6.99- The Upstate (Egg Sandwich)
Just egg. That’s it. No frills, no thrills — just a fluffy egg tucked inside your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Simple, honest, and maybe a little too proud of it.
$6.49- Lady Liberty (Egg White, Avocado, Pesto, Arugula & Cheese)
Egg whites, creamy avocado spread, vibrant pesto, fresh arugula, and melted cheese, all layered on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Light, fresh, and just bold enough to stand tall.
$9.99- The Park Avenue (Lox Bagel Sandwich)
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, capers, tomato, and red onion stacked on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. We recommend it with our chive cream cheese for the perfect savory bite. A timeless favorite, fresh and full of flavor.
$16.49- The Texan (OAK’D Prime Brisket, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich)
Oaked prime brisket, egg and cheese.
$12.99 Cold Lunch Sandwiches & Salads
-
- New York, New York (Italian Sandwich)
Classic Italian deli flavors piled high: ham, salami, and provolone with banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, finished with oregano, oil & vinegar, salt, and pepper — all on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Bold, zesty, and straight from the heart of a true Italian sandwich shop.
$11.99- The Streisand (Chicken Salad)
Our house-made chicken salad, topped with crisp lettuce and fresh tomato, served on your choice of a freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagel. A fresh, flavorful classic that never goes out of style.
$11.49- Greenwich Village (Turkey & Provolone)
Sliced turkey breast, provolone cheese, crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and red onion, finished with oil & vinegar, mayo, salt, and pepper — all stacked on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A fresh, satisfying bite that hits every time. Try it with one of our house made cream cheeses!
$11.99- The HighLine (Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato)
Crispy bacon, crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and a drizzle of mayo, piled onto your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A no-nonsense classic done the right way.
$8.49- The Central Park (Caesar Salad)
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, shaved parmesan, and crunchy croutons. A fresh, classic Caesar salad that's simple, satisfying, and timeless.
$10.49 Hot Lunch Sandwiches
-
- The Flat Iron (Cheesesteak)
Your choice of chopped steak or chicken, grilled with peppers and onions, layered with melted cheese and a drizzle of mayo, all served on a freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagel. Big, bold, and packed with classic Philly flavor..
$11.99- The Buffalo, New York (Buffalo Chicken, Coleslaw, Pickles)
Spicy buffalo chicken, crisp coleslaw, tangy pickles, and melted pepper jack cheese, stacked on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Bold, messy, and packed with serious flavor — just like the Buffalo Bills: all heart, a little chaos, and impossible to ignore.
$11.49- The Brooklyn (Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss, Russian Dressing)
Tender pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing, all stacked on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. A bold, classic sandwich with true New York attitude.
$11.99- The Queen’s Boulevard (Chicken Caesar Salad)
Crispy fried chicken and fresh Caesar salad piled high on your choice of our freshly baked, kettle-boiled New York-style bagels. Built like Vince’s breakout role in Queen’s Boulevard — gritty, over the top, and way better than Medellin.
$10.99 Sides & Extras
-
- Kettle Chips
Kettle-cooked Mrs. Vickie’s chips
$2.09- Hashbrown Side
Crispy, golden-brown hash brown patty—griddled to perfection with a soft, fluffy inside and crunchy edges. A classic breakfast side fried in 100% peanut oil.
$2.09- Side of Bacon
Two pieces of bacon on the side.
$3.14- Side of Breakfast Sausage
One Sausage Patty
$3.14 Hot House Beverages
-
- Brewed Coffee (12oz)
House-brewed coffee.
$2.52- Brewed Coffee (16oz)
House-brewed coffee.
$3.52- Hot Tea (12oz)
Cup of hot tea. Flavor of choice.
$2.89- Hot Tea (16oz)
Cup of hot tea. Flavor of choice.
$3.89- Espresso
Rich and bold. Enjoy a single shot or upgrade to a double or triple for an extra boost.
$3.93- Latte (12oz)
Smooth and creamy espresso blended with steamed milk. Customize with your choice of milk or flavor.
$5.09- Latte (16oz)
Smooth and creamy espresso blended with steamed milk. Customize with your choice of milk or flavor.
$6.09- Cappuccino (12oz)
Bold espresso with steamed milk and a thick layer of foam.
$5.09- Cappuccino (16oz)
Bold espresso with steamed milk and a thick layer of foam.
$6.09- Mocha (12oz)
Rich espresso blended with steamed milk and chocolate.
$5.09- Mocha (16oz)
Rich espresso blended with steamed milk and chocolate.
$6.09- Americano (12oz)
Freshly pulled espresso diluted with hot water for a smooth, bold coffee.
$4.71- Americano (16oz)
Freshly pulled espresso diluted with hot water for a smooth, bold coffee.
$5.71- Chai Latte (12oz)
A warm blend of spiced chai and steamed milk—smooth, comforting, and lightly sweet.
$5.51- Chai Latte (16oz)
A warm blend of spiced chai and steamed milk—smooth, comforting, and lightly sweet.
$6.51- Hot Chocolate (12oz)
Steamed milk mixed with rich Monin chocolate syrup for a smooth, cozy treat.
$3.94- Hot Chocolate (16oz)
Steamed milk mixed with rich Monin chocolate syrup for a smooth, cozy treat.
$4.94- Candybar Latte (12oz)
A beautiful mix of caramel, white chocolate, and dark chocolate.
$6.80- Candybar Latte (16oz)
A beautiful mix of caramel, white chocolate, and dark chocolate.
$7.80- Snickerdoodle Latte (12oz)
A mix of white chocolate and cinnamon.
$6.80- Snickerdoodle Latte (16oz)
A mix of white chocolate and cinnamon.
$7.80- Matcha Latte (12oz)
Now serving smooth, earthy matcha blended with steamed milk. Lightly sweetened.
$7.49- Matcha Latte (16oz)
Now serving smooth, earthy matcha blended with steamed milk. Lightly sweetened.
$8.49 Cold House Beverages
-
- Iced Coffee (16oz)
House iced coffee.
$3.15- Iced Latte (16oz)
Iced Latte
$5.61- Iced Mocha (16oz)
Iced Mocha
$5.61- Iced Americano (16oz)
Iced Americano
$4.71- Unsweetened House Iced Tea (16oz)
Unsweetened House Iced Tea
$2.63- Peach House Iced Tea
Peach House Iced Tea
$2.73- Iced Chai Latte (16oz)
Iced Chai Latte
$5.51- Iced Snickerdoodle Latte (16oz)
A mix of white chocolate and cinnamon.
$6.80- Iced Candybar Latte (16oz)
A beautiful mix of caramel, white chocolate, and dark chocolate.
$6.80- Iced Matcha (16oz)
Matcha sourced from Japan. We recommend adding vanilla or lavender.
$7.49- Cold Brew (16oz)
Cold brew.
$5.36 Beverages
-
- Gatorade - Can
Gatorade.
$3.03- Orange Juice - Bottle
Orange Juice.
$3.14- Apple Juice - Bottle
Apple Juice.
$3.14- Water - Bottle
Water.
$3.14- Topo Chico - Bottle
Topo Chico.
$3.14- Lowfat Chocolate Milk
Lowfat Chocolate Milk
$2.99- Lowfat Organic Milk
Lowfat Organic Milk
$2.99- Jarritos Strawberry - Bottle
Jarritos Strawberry.
$3.14
